Selected corrections to the first edition of Michael Ignatieff, Isaiah Berlin: A Life
As the first biographer who used the Isaiah Berlin Papers, before they were deposited in the Bodleian Library in Oxford, where they were catalogued and foliated, and before the four-volume edition of Berlin’s letters (2004–15) had appeared, Michael Ignatieff did not have ready access to all the sources that he would have been able to use had he been starting afresh once this process had been completed; he was also under pressure to complete his task within a short time after Berlin’s death on 5 November 1997. The first edition of his biography was therefore considerably revised for its second, updated edition (2023).
In order that students of Berlin should not be misled or travel up blind alleys in the twenty-five years intervening between the two editions, a web page was established to list selected corrections of or additions to the first edition. Much of this list is preserved below, for the benefit of those still using the first edition.
The second edition incorporated all the information provided here, adding references to the Isaiah Berlin Papers and the published letters, as well as to other publications that appeared after the first edition went to press. A separate list of errors and other issues in the second edition is here.
Errors corrected in the paperback edition (2000) appear in this colour. Occasionally they are further corrected in the second edition (2023).
Page in 1st/2nd edition |
[Note]/line in 1st edition |
For | Read |
xi/ix | 6 | Yitzka | Yitzhak |
1/1 | 1 | The Albany | Albany |
5/5 | 13 | Kempf | Kempff |
11/12 | 4 | Eli | Elkanah |
12/13 | 16 | river | canal |
15/18 | 5–4 up | one of the daughters of the Zemach Zadek |
one of the granddaughters of the Zemach Zedek |
17 | 9–8 up | 13 March 1906. She was twenty- six, he was twenty-three. |
14 (old style)/27 (new style) March 1906. She was twenty-four, he was twenty-one. |
19/21 | 1–2 | Scheissemusik […] shit music | Schreiemusik […] screaming music |
23/25 | 17 | Kvorost | Khvorost |
25/28 | 18 | autumn of 1917 | summer of 1917 |
27/30 | 17–16 up | Two of her sisters, Ida […] and Evgenia […], were |
Marie’s sister Ida […] and Mendel’s sister Evgenia […] were |
32/36 | 2 | 3 February | 20 February |
42/47 | 10 | the spring of | late |
48/54 | 1 | five- | seven- |
54/62 | 11 up | Giovanezza | Giovinezza |
64/73 | 8 | tight, | very tight |
65/74 | 4 | dish | saucer |
65/75 | 23 | in the front garden | in front of the house |
66/76 | 18 | Nicholson’s | Nicolson’s |
68/77 | 2 | Mill House | The Mill House |
69/79 | 12 up | a state hospital in | [delete] |
75/86 | 8 up | andere Farbingen | anderen Farbigen |
81/93 | 12 up | his | Ayer’s |
90/103 | 18 | Blaskett | Blasket |
92/105 | 8 | Avenue | Lane |
101/115 | 14 | informing | ordering |
102/116 | 11 | Heyman | Hillman |
107/122 | 2 | Grand Central | Penn |
120/138 | 5 up | whole-scale | wholesale |
129/148 | 6 | hare | the hare |
161/185 | 19 | Marinsky | Mariinsky |
168/194 | last | arrest, trial and execution of fifteen | arrest and torture of nine |
177/220 | 8 | blew up | bombed |
186/231 | 16 | October | September and October |
199/246 | 14 up | Die | Der |
202/250 | 11 | positive and negative | negative and positive |
204/252 | 10 up | BBC Radio’s | the Third Programme |
205/253 | 3–4 | the ‘Paganini of the platform’ | ‘a Paganini of ideas’ |
206/255 | 13 up | apologia pro sua vita | apologia pro vita sua |
212/261 | 18 up | America in 1940 | England in 1940 |
14 up | for the duration of the war | until 1944 | |
217/267 | 12 up | Cry, child, cry | Cry, my child, cry |
218/268 | 15 | Cocteau’s mistress | [delete] |
225/276 | 13 up | 1961 | 1960 |
230/282 | 16 | Bloom | Gewirth |
244/298 | 6 up | Some Sources of Romanticism | Sources of Romantic Thought |
247/301 | 14 | 1950s | 1940s |
251/306 | 18/19 | one of them | a young colleague |
268/326 | 5 | No. 60 | No. 60 (with no. 47 across the road added later for offices) |
293/357 | 20 | Chief | former Chief |
300/364 | 1 | betsror | bitsror hachaim |
300/365 | 2 up | minor | flat major |
303/367 | [replace everything from this point onwards with what appears in the second edition: the notes have been so extensively revised that it is not practicable to list specific corrections] |